Broadcasting Minister New Zealand Melissa Lee faces heat over newshub closure and media support legislation

Broadcasting Minister Melissa Lee has been under intense scrutiny following the announcement of Newshub’s impending closure, with critics accusing her of avoiding in-depth media engagements. Despite widespread criticism, Lee insists she has been available, citing her conversation with The Spinoff’s Duncan Greive as evidence of her engagement. The situation brings to the forefront the challenges facing the media industry and the government’s stance on the Fair Digital Media Bargaining Bill.

Initial response and public scrutiny
Lee’s initial reaction to Newshub’s closure news was met with disapproval from both media commentators and opposition members, who described her as either glib or absent. Despite attempts to address these concerns in subsequent public appearances and an interview with Duncan Greive, where she expressed shock and sympathy towards the affected Newshub staff, Lee’s reluctance to participate in one-on-one broadcast interviews has fueled further criticism. Her laughter in response to inquiries about future interviews, coupled with vague commitments, has done little to quell the perception of evasion.

Legislative background and future prospects
The closure of Newshub has reignited discussions around the Fair Digital Media Bargaining Bill, designed to support local media by requiring digital platforms to compensate for content use. Lee, who had previously criticized the bill as a ‘shakedown,’ now faces pressure to reconsider her stance in light of Newshub’s situation. The potential benefits of the bill, which include creating a fairer revenue-sharing model and securing the future of local media, contrast sharply with the current uncertainty and instability within the industry.

Political reactions and industry i mplications
Opposition members, particularly Labour’s broadcasting spokesperson Willie Jackson, have criticized Lee’s handling of the issue, suggesting that her inaction reflects poorly on her judgment and commitment to supporting the media sector. The debate extends beyond political lines, touching on broader concerns about media sustainability, public interest journalism, and the role of government in ensuring a diverse and robust press. As the bill progresses through the select committee, the outcome will likely influence not only the future of Newshub but also the broader landscape of New Zealand media.

As the story of Newshub’s closure unfolds, the spotlight on Minister Melissa Lee and the proposed Fair Digital Media Bargaining Bill highlights critical issues facing the media industry. With the potential for significant legal and financial implications, the situation serves as a pivotal moment for both the government and digital platforms in shaping the future of news media in New Zealand. Whether this controversy will catalyze change or further entrench existing challenges remains to be seen, but it undoubtedly marks a critical juncture in the ongoing debate over media sustainability and support. BNN Breaking